Last November, we found out that Ted Haggard had possibly been involved in a homosexual relationship. As I was considering what this meant, I stumbled across a
story by Brian McLaren on the homosexual issue. Several months later I saw a
comment on Pastor Chet’s blog about the same issue, a conversation which I took a small part in. Through all of this, I have been conversing with a friend, who has struggled with homosexuality in the past and is also a Christian, about the struggles they have had, and sometimes still have. As we talked, he expressed a desire to share his story, and some of his struggles and concerns, but didn’t feel he had a safe avenue in which to do it. We came to the conclusion that he could use my blog to do so. He wrote a letter, and I helped him edit it to remove any trace of his identity. As I was getting ready to post this, I saw that
Todd had linked to a
Christianity Today article on homosexuality and change.
Now, before you read this letter, please note that you should not assume that either myself or the author of the letter believe something specific or hold a certain position unless it is EXPLICITLY STATED. Also, please remember that as you comment, you are commenting on a letter by a real live breathing human being who has feelings, and has been brave enough to stick his neck out.
Well, without any further ado…I present to you “Steve”:
When I was in Junior High School, I saw Top Gun, the 1986 Tom Cruise movie, and I realized that something was wrong. I realized that I was attracted to Tom Cruise. In a moment of reflection, I began to realize that I had never really had any attraction for girls whatsoever, and that I had actually been attracted to several other guys. Had it not been for a news report about AIDS several evenings prior, and an ensuing conversation about what it was and where it came from amongst myself, my siblings and my father, I would never have given my attraction to Tom Cruise a second thought. Over the next year I came to the realization that I was more sexually attracted to guys than girls. The shock, fear and angst that came with this revelation scared meto death.
Growing up in an evangelical church didn’t make things any easier. Trying to find someone with whom I could talk was out of the question. Admittedly, things are quite a bit different now than they were back then, but telling Christians you are “gay” immediately gets you branded. It didn’t really matter that I was at church every Sunday and Wednesday, nor that I was the one person everyone could look to when a question about the Bible needed answered. Nor would it matter that I was considered one of the most faithful leaders of our church’s small youth group. The few girlfriends I did have would always wonder whether I really liked them, or if I was just using them as cover, and most, if not all, of my guy friends would wonder if I had ulterior motives in my friendships with them.
The fact is, other than a pretty big problem with pornography, I have never put any action into this sexual attraction. While this certainly eases the blow, it comes with its own issues, such as people assuming that it isn’t really a true struggle for me, or that it might just be a passing phase. Still, no matter what my other personality traits, interests or even life callings, I am still seen and treated as the one who “struggles with homosexuality”.
It seems as though most of the conversations about homosexuality in the church are somewhat abstract. But the fact is that I’m a real person who has struggled through this mine-field looking for an answer. I certainly don’t believe that God is for homosexuality, but what was I to do with these feelings? What are others who struggle in this way to do with these feelings?
Here are some of issues that I wrestled, and at times still wrestle with:
- Most Christians readily assume that homosexuality is wrong, and frankly, I agree with them. However, I can also think of Christians who lived in the South before abolition that were convinced that slavery, and other such injustices, were right, and even biblical. Will future Christians realize they were wrong about this issue too? Have I suffered for naught? I really don’t think this is going to happen, but the question still lingers in my mind.
- More “progressive” evangelicals are placing more emphasis on orientation. For example, they understand that homosexual activity is sin, but the orientation is not a choice. While this is somewhat better than “Hate the sin, but not the sinner”, it still fails to see how deeply rooted the orientation is in our personality. The attraction is as real and “natural” to us as heterosexual attraction to others. It isn’t just about lust. It isn’t just about sex. It is far more complex than that. The differentiation between orientation and action is helpful for basic understanding, but in reality-in our hearts & minds & bodies, we are one.
- Gay marriage has been the hot topic. While I believe that no law should require a Christian church (or any religion) to perform such unions, I am not sure I believe it is right to make them illegal. If the argument is based on God’s design for marriage, sexuality, family and cultural responsibility-thus a Biblical, Christian world view-does this not, then also mean that we should stand against the understanding of marriage that undermines this? Shouldn’t Islamic or Hindu marriages, where the role, position and (often) even the value of women is in direct contradiction to Judeo-Christians be fought against as well? Shouldn’t common-law marriages receive the same press and emotion from the Christian community? I say all this, not to be political, but to demonstrate that the fierce commitment against these “evils” is not being honestly addressed.
-”Steve”